Carol Fay

Carol Fay

Carol Fay Walloon Lake Properties

Languages Spoken:

  • English
  • 231-330-0876
  • 231-347-7600
Contact Me

Personal Interests

Carol loves living on Walloon Lake and whenever possible spends time enjoying the water.  She often shows lake property by boat and feels it is  the perfect way to give a customer the best lake experience. 

Reading is another of Carol's pleasures as well as going to see a good movie!




  Residential Home Search
  Waterfront Home Search




Personal Background

Carol and her husband Robert have been married for 34 years.  Before Carol became a Realtor and Robert became a master electrician and builder, they owned six Midas Muffler Shops.  They have two children, a daughter Abbey who is an assistant principal in Raleigh, North Carolina and a son Tripp.  Tripp lives in Colorado and is the Content Specialist at Copper Mountain.  Robert and Carol have one grandchild, Emma, who was born on 12-12-12, which was her due date!  And is the apple of their eye!

Professional Interests

Carol lives on Walloon Lake and has a vast knowledge of waterfront property.

She can help you find  the perfect property whether it be on Crooked Lake, Burt Lake, Lake Charlevoix or the surrounding areas. 

Carol is a member of the Chamber of Commerce, a member of the Michigan Association of Realtors and the National Association of Realtors.

Carol has served on the Advisory Board of First Community Bank.

Professional Background

Carol has had the pleasure of selling real estate in beautiful Northern Michigan for 22 years.

Carol is very enthusiastic and passionate about her work.

She is very knowledgeable and a skilled negotiator.

She is an Accredited Buyer Representative and a Luxury Home Specialist. 

She is consistently a top producer.


Real Estate around the world

Ask me how I can help you with your real estate needs all around the world!


Luxury homes

Luxury waterfront homes

Residential real estate

Condominium sales

New home sales


  • Accredited Buyer Representative
  • Coldwell Banker Chairman's Circle
  • Realtor
  • Equal Housing Opportunity
  • Global Luxury Specialist


"Carol assisted us with selling our house during the winter of 2015-16. She had helped us to sell a house in the past, and as that experience was quite good, we didn't even think twice about going to her again. We asked Carol to come over to assess what preliminary work should be done in order to put the house on the market; she gave good advice, and knew of local handymen to help us with those projects, if necessary.

As we were selling the house from long-distance, there were several occasions when we couldn't be there to see to something, such as turning off the water after a showing (or turning it back on), checking the house to determine if we were on track in readying it for sale, keeping us informed as to the snowplowing of the driveway, etc. When the time came to negotiate on the sale itself, Carol gave excellent advice on how to proceed next. At every step along the way, Carol was responsive in a timely manner and had good, positive ideas as to the next step. There is a reason why she has such a fine reputation in the area as a realtor, and she has worked hard and consistently to earn it."
~ kjartist9


"Carol was an integral part of the sale of my condo. I've worked with Carol on the sale/purchase of 3 homes. She is the epitome of professionalism and knowledge. She gives sound advice and we had an offer in just 3 weeks!! I would highly recommend Carol as 'your' realtor."
~ Sherri G.


"Carol Fay is a great Realtor. She helped me through every step of the process. She is VERY familiar with northern Michigan. She is also very honest, quick to return your calls and a great negotiator."
~ Jim T.


"Carol is honest and exceptionally knowledgable about the market. She helped us at every stage of the process - from staging the home, to pricing, to scheduling showings, to negotiating the deal. We had an offer within 24 hours of listing our home. She was truly excellent to work with and we highly recommend her."
~ Patrick J.


"Carol helped with the sale of our family home after the passing of our parents. I relied heavily on Carol's years of experience during the whole process of listing, showing, negotiating and closing of a much loved home. Carol understood the local market and offered timely and thoughtful advise via phone and email, as I live in a different state. It was wonderful to have a someone locally watching over the home and the market trends."
~ Linda G.


"Carol understands the value of real estate and she values a quality transaction between buyer and seller! She has helped us more than once - buying and selling.
~ Polly C.